I may be in a minority here, but it’s getting harder and harder to tell when I’m watching politics from when I’m reading the conversations on some of my favorite blogs these days. As things change, money comes into the picture and a new wave of bloggers emerges, the “vibe” inside the social media bubble is feeling a lot less hospitable.
I don’t want to get lost in the who are the Republicans and who are the Democrats nonsense (although it would be a funny post if anyone else wants to write the damn thing), but what I do want to point out is this… At the moment, no matter what your leanings are, it has always been difficult to have a political conversation and it is starting to feel similar in Social Media.
I don’t want you to think this post is about any one thing and I don’t want you to think I’m avoiding naming names. It isn’t and I’m not. Simply put, I think all of us have lost our collective shit a little and we could all use a little perspective.
It’s not that there aren’t rational people out there. It’s not that there aren’t kick-ass people on both sides of the divide that has emerged (or at least widened significantly). It’s that the noise has completely overwhelmed the logic. It’s gotten to the point where you can’t disagree or have an unpopular opinion without being labeled a “hater” (officially the world’s stupidest word ever for those keeping score). It’s gotten to the point where questioning someone who may be considered an A-lister (another really stupid term that is quickly gaining on hater) is enough to get you tarred and feathered.
Call me crazy but I’m a fan of nuance, a fan of debate and a fan of taking a stance and potentially (read: often) being wrong. It is one of the reasons I’ve never fared well in political conversations. However these odd little quirks were what drew me to the social web in the first place. It was new, it was growing and it encouraged us to question every thing and every one. We had to do it with respect, but there wasn’t much that was off limits. We were all learning together, everyone from those just starting out to those at the top of this emerging game.
Nowadays it seems as we’ve joined teams, political parties if you will, that are spending more time attacking or dismissing one another than discussing the work that we love. The energy that once drove the space is slowly but surely turning into ire against one another. It’s sad, it’s unfortunate and it’s getting to the point where it is harmful.
Polarizing opinions are a good thing, but only when they lead to the kind of debate that fosters innovation… only when they inevitably lead to middle ground. Otherwise, it is just political rhetoric, plain and simple. Most of these once productive conversations have become severely adversarial or have stopped altogether. Worse yet, it’s the kind of rhetoric that takes away from the sense of community that helped this space get to where it is today. A feeling that is quickly being replaced by anger, jealousy, resentment and hate, just like the exceptionally hostile and unproductive political climate we see all around us today.
Michael Schechter is the Digital Marketing Director for Honora Pearls, a company specializing in freshwater pearl jewelry. He writes about all things digital over at his blog, and you can connect with him on Twitter at @MSchechter.
- 6 May 2013 : Knowing Your Audience: How PR Agencies Need to be Careful Choosing Customers
- 30 April 2013 : Get Geoff Livingston’s Welcome to the Fifth Estate Free
- 19 April 2013 : Auto-tweets, Kawasaki and Takedowns: The Ugly Side of Social
- 15 April 2013 : 2013: The Year that Social Media Will Run out of Kool-Aid
- 8 April 2013 : Top 5 Tips for Adapting a Relationship Marketing Model